Highest Offer When Selling Your Home

You may receive multiple offers for your house and one may be significantly higher than the others. You shouldn’t automatically accept the highest offer because it may have strings attached that won’t work for you. Someone who offered you a lower price may be able to close with less of a hassle.

Financing

Most homebuyers take out a mortgage. The approval process takes time and borrowers can hit a number of snags along the way. A potential buyer may not get approved for the amount needed or the house may appraise for less than the price you agreed on. If the buyer can’t make up the difference, the deal may fall through. A buyer who offers cash won’t have to clear any of those hurdles. It may be better to accept a lower price and not have to deal with additional stress.

If no one offers you cash, a preapproval letter is the next best thing. That means a potential buyer has gotten approved for a large enough loan to buy your house. A buyer who is preapproved and offers you less money may be more appealing than someone who makes a higher offer but doesn’t have proof of financing.

Closing Date 

Sellers and buyers often want to close as soon as possible after agreeing on a price. Sometimes, one party can’t do that or doesn’t want to. 

You may have already moved out and may be paying two mortgages. If you’re eager to sell your old house, but a buyer can’t close right away, you may decide to accept a lower offer from someone who can close quickly. If you haven’t found a new house yet, or if you’re having your new home renovated and won’t be able to move in for several months, you may decide to accept a lower offer from someone who is in no hurry to get the keys to your current home.

Contingencies and Concessions

Buyers often include contingencies in an offer letter. Contingencies related to an inspection are common. A buyer may also want to make a purchase contingent on getting financing, having the house appraised for at least the asking price, or selling their current home. If a problem arises in any of those areas, the sale can be delayed or may not be possible at all. A seller who makes a high offer may also ask you to throw in some big-ticket items that you weren’t planning to leave behind, such as appliances or a hot tub. You may choose to accept a lower offer from a buyer with fewer contingencies and requests for concessions. 

Emotion

Some potential buyers write a letter to a seller explaining why they want to buy the house and how they picture their family living there. If you received two or more similar offers, an emotional connection with one family may be the deciding factor.

Related Posts

ABOUT US

Joseph A. Zingales is a Broker in the State of Ohio, a Broker in the State of Florida, the Principal of The Zingales Team and has been a licensed Real Estate Agent since January 1998.

Licensed/Certified: Broker, Realtor®, Appraiser, and Home Stager.

©2025 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of HomeServices of America, Inc. ® Equal Housing Opportunity.

The Zingales Team: Licensed/Certified Broker, Realtors®, Appraisers, and Home Stagers

Address: 7466 Auburn Road Suite A, Concord, Ohio 44077

Email: info@ohiohomeservices.net

Office: 440-296-5006

FOLLOW US

MLS-Realtor-Equal Housing Opportunity
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Fair HousingAccessibility
© 2025 Zingales Real Estate Enterprises LLC